Open the app
  1. Home
  2. Lessons
  3. GCSE Psychology
  4. Punishment and recidivism

Punishment and recidivism

🎬 The doodle video for this lesson is coming soon. Subscribe on YouTube to see it first.

Does punishment stop people reoffending? Recidivism means committing crime again after being punished. Different punishments have different effects.

Prison

Prison removes offenders from society. It aims to punish, deter (put people off crime), protect the public and rehabilitate (change behaviour through education and treatment).
Strengths: it protects the public while the offender is inside, can deter some people, and gives time for rehabilitation programmes.
Weaknesses: many prisoners reoffend after release. Prisoners may learn new criminal skills from other prisoners (social learning). Offenders can lose jobs, homes and family ties, making it harder to go straight. It is expensive.

Community sentencing

The offender stays in the community but must follow conditions, such as unpaid work, a curfew, regular meetings with probation officers, or treatment (for example for drug use).
Strengths: offenders can keep jobs and family links, which helps them avoid crime. It is cheaper than prison, and unpaid work pays back the community. It avoids contact with other criminals in prison.
Weaknesses: the public may see it as too soft, so it may deter less. It is not suitable for dangerous offenders. Some offenders break the conditions.

Restorative justice

The offender and victim (or the community) meet, with a trained facilitator, if both agree. The victim explains the harm caused, and the offender takes responsibility, may apologise and may repair the damage.
Strengths: offenders see the real effect of their crime, which may build empathy and reduce reoffending. Victims get a voice and can feel more in control.
Weaknesses: both sides must agree, so it cannot always be used. Meeting the offender could upset the victim again. An offender may fake remorse to get a lighter outcome.
Worked example

A 17-year-old is caught spraying graffiti on a community centre. Suggest one punishment and explain why it might reduce recidivism.

  1. Restorative justice: the teenager meets the people who run the centre and cleans the wall.
  2. Seeing the harm caused may build empathy, and repairing the damage takes responsibility.

Answer: Restorative justice, because understanding the harm and repairing it may make the teenager less likely to reoffend.

Key idea

Recidivism means reoffending. Prison protects the public but many reoffend and may learn crime inside. Community sentences keep job and family ties and are cheaper, but may seem soft. Restorative justice builds empathy and helps victims, but needs both sides to agree.

Check you have got it

Answer 6 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.

Practise this lesson free (6 questions)All GCSE Psychology lessons