Key study: Charlton et al (2000)
Charlton et al (2000), 'Children's Playground Behaviour Across Five Years of Broadcast Television: A Naturalistic Study in a Remote Community', tested whether TV makes children more aggressive.
Aim and setting
Setting: St Helena, a small, remote British island in the South Atlantic, which did not have broadcast TV until the mid-1990s. This made it a natural experiment: the researchers did not introduce TV, it happened naturally.
Participants: children aged about 3 to 8 at the island's schools.
Procedure and results
The recordings were coded using a checklist of pro-social behaviours (such as helping or sharing) and antisocial behaviours (such as hitting or pushing). Two coders checked each other's coding for inter-rater reliability.
Results: there was very little change in behaviour after TV arrived. Most comparisons showed no significant difference, and the few that did were mixed. Boys showed more antisocial acts than girls, both before and after TV.
Conclusion and evaluation
Strengths: high ecological validity: real children in a real playground. It was longitudinal (over several years). Video recordings could be checked by more than one coder, improving reliability.
Weaknesses: St Helena is unusual (small and close-knit), so results may not generalise to larger cities. As a natural experiment, other variables could not be controlled. How much TV each child watched was not measured.
Why was St Helena a good place for this study?
- It had no broadcast TV until the mid-1990s.
- So researchers could record behaviour before and after TV arrived, as a natural experiment.
Answer: It allowed a before-and-after comparison of the same community when TV arrived naturally.
Charlton et al (2000) filmed children's playground behaviour on St Helena before and after TV arrived and found little change. TV did not increase aggression, perhaps because the community was close and supportive. The study is high in ecological validity but hard to generalise.
- Ecological validity
- How far results apply to real-life settings.
- Validity
- Accuracy: whether a study measures what it claims to and whether results apply beyond the study.
- Natural experiment
- An experiment in which the IV occurs naturally rather than being manipulated by the researcher.
- Reliability
- Consistency: a reliable measure or study gives the same results if repeated.
Try two quick questions
See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.
2 more questions
Try each one, then tap to check.
When did broadcast TV arrive on St Helena?
- 1955
- 2005
- 1975
- 1995
Show the answer
Answer: 1995
TV arrived in 1995.
Why was Charlton et al.'s study a natural experiment?
- The researchers installed the TV
- It took place in a lab
- The arrival of TV was not controlled by the researchers
- It used a Bobo doll
Show the answer
Answer: The arrival of TV was not controlled by the researchers
The independent variable occurred naturally.
Check you have got it
Answer 7 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.
- Pearson Edexcel GCSE Psychology (1PS0) specification
- Study Mind: Charlton et al. (2000) revision notes
Facts checked against the sources below, 16 October 2026. Last updated 2 October 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.
What do exam command words like explain and evaluate mean? โ