Language and thought: Piaget and Vygotsky
Which comes first: thinking or language? Piaget (1950) and Vygotsky (1981) gave different answers.
Piaget (1950): thought comes first
For example, a baby develops object permanence (knowing an object still exists when hidden) before using words for objects.
So language depends on cognitive development: it reflects the thinking a child can already do. Young children's early speech is egocentric (focused on themselves) and becomes more social as their thinking develops.
Strengths: fits the order in which children develop; supported by observations of children's thinking before speech.
Weaknesses: it may underestimate how language helps thinking; for example, learning words can help children form new concepts.
Vygotsky (1981): separate at first, then joined
Pre-linguistic thought: thinking without language. A baby can recognise a parent or solve simple problems without words.
Pre-intellectual language: using sounds without thought behind them, such as babbling, crying or copying words to get attention.
At around age 2, the two come together: thought becomes verbal and speech becomes rational. Children talk aloud to guide themselves (private speech), which later becomes silent inner speech.
Language is learned through social interaction, and then shapes thinking.
Strengths: recognises the importance of social interaction; explains why children talk to themselves when solving problems.
Weaknesses: inner speech is hard to observe and test; the theory is less detailed about how the two join.
Comparing the theories
| Item | Piaget (1950) | Vygotsky (1981) |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship | Thought comes first; language follows | Separate at first, then joined at about age 2 |
| Role of language | Reflects thinking | Shapes thinking |
| Key terms | Representational thinking, egocentric speech | Pre-linguistic thought, pre-intellectual language, inner speech |
| Main influence | The child's own cognitive development | Social interaction with others |
A 1-year-old searches for a toy hidden under a blanket but has no words yet. Which theory does this support, and why?
- The child has a mental representation of the toy (object permanence).
- This happens before the child has words, so thought comes before language.
Answer: Piaget's theory: representational thinking comes before language.
Piaget (1950) said representational thinking comes before language, so language reflects thought. Vygotsky (1981) said pre-linguistic thought and pre-intellectual language develop separately and join at about age 2, after which language shapes thinking through private and inner speech.
Try two quick questions
See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.
2 more questions
Try each one, then tap to check.
According to Piaget, which comes first in development?
- Language
- Both arrive together
- Neither
- Thought
Show the answer
Answer: Thought
Children need mental representations before words.
What did Vygotsky call thinking without words in infants?
- Pre-intellectual language
- Inner speech
- Pre-linguistic thought
- Egocentric speech
Show the answer
Answer: Pre-linguistic thought
Thought exists before language.
Check you have got it
Answer 7 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.
Facts checked against the sources below, 17 October 2026. Last updated 2 October 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.
What do exam command words like explain and evaluate mean? โ