Laboratory, field and natural experiments
In an experiment, the researcher looks at the effect of an IV on a DV. There are three types, depending on where it happens and who controls the IV.
Three types of experiment
Field experiment: in a natural, everyday setting (such as a street, school or train). The researcher still manipulates the IV. Example: Piliavin et al (1969) staged collapses on a New York subway train.
Natural experiment: the IV occurs naturally: the researcher does not manipulate it, just measures its effect. Example: Charlton et al (2000) studied the arrival of TV on St Helena.
Strengths and weaknesses
| Type | Strengths | Weaknesses |
|---|---|---|
| Laboratory | High control, so cause and effect can be shown; standardised, so easy to replicate (reliable) | Artificial, so low ecological validity; demand characteristics |
| Field | Natural setting, so higher ecological validity; participants often unaware, so fewer demand characteristics | Less control of extraneous variables; harder to replicate; ethical issues (consent, deception) |
| Natural | Allows study of things it would be unethical or impossible to manipulate; high ecological validity | No control over the IV or allocation; cannot be sure of cause and effect; rare events are hard to replicate |
Telling them apart
1. Did the researcher change the IV? If no, it is a natural experiment.
2. If yes, was it in an artificial setting or a real-life one? Artificial: laboratory. Real life: field.
Researchers compare children's reading scores in schools before and after a new national phonics policy is introduced by the government. What type of experiment is this?
- The government introduced the policy, not the researcher, so the IV occurred naturally.
- So it is a natural experiment.
Answer: A natural experiment.
Lab experiments manipulate the IV in a controlled setting (high control and reliability, low ecological validity). Field experiments manipulate the IV in a natural setting (more realistic, less control). Natural experiments study an IV that occurs naturally (realistic and ethical, but cause and effect is uncertain).
- Reliability
- Consistency: a reliable measure or study gives the same results if repeated.
- Ecological validity
- How far results apply to real-life settings.
- Validity
- Accuracy: whether a study measures what it claims to and whether results apply beyond the study.
- Laboratory experiment
- An experiment in a controlled, artificial setting in which the researcher manipulates the IV.
- Field experiment
- An experiment in a natural, everyday setting in which the researcher still manipulates the IV.
- Natural experiment
- An experiment in which the IV occurs naturally rather than being manipulated by the researcher.
Try two quick questions
See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.
2 more questions
Try each one, then tap to check.
Which is a field experiment?
- Testing memory in a laboratory
- Studying how a natural disaster affects stress
- Testing whether people help a lost child in a real shopping centre
- Studying one patient with amnesia
Show the answer
Answer: Testing whether people help a lost child in a real shopping centre
The IV is manipulated in a real setting.
What is a natural experiment?
- The IV is manipulated in a lab
- The IV is manipulated in a real setting
- The IV occurs naturally and is not manipulated by the researcher
- There is no IV
Show the answer
Answer: The IV occurs naturally and is not manipulated by the researcher
Charlton et al. is an example.
Check you have got it
Answer 7 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.
- Pearson Edexcel GCSE Psychology (1PS0) specification
- Simply Psychology: Piliavin et al. (1969) subway study
- Study Mind: Charlton et al. (2000) revision notes
Facts checked against the sources below, 16 October 2026. Last updated 2 October 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.
What do exam command words like explain and evaluate mean? โ