Controlling extraneous variables
Researchers use several techniques to control extraneous variables so that only the IV affects the DV.
Standardisation, counterbalancing and randomisation
Counterbalancing: used in repeated measures designs. Half the participants do condition A then B; the other half do B then A. This balances out order effects (practice, boredom, tiredness). Strength: order effects affect both conditions equally. Weakness: it does not remove order effects, only spreads them.
Randomisation: using chance to decide things, such as which participants go in which group, or the order of items. Strength: reduces researcher bias and spreads participant variables evenly. Weakness: by chance, groups can still end up unequal.
Single-blind and double-blind
Double-blind: neither the participants nor the researcher who collects the data know which condition each participant is in. Strength: reduces both participant and researcher bias. Weakness: harder and more expensive to organise.
Example: in a drug trial, some people get the real tablet and some get a placebo (a fake). In a double-blind trial, neither they nor the person testing them knows which they got.
Choosing the right control
| Problem | Control |
|---|---|
| Participants get better in the second condition because of practice | Counterbalancing |
| Different instructions given to different people | Standardised procedures |
| Researcher might put the brightest people in one group | Randomisation (random allocation) |
| Participants guess the aim and act differently | Single-blind |
| Researcher's expectations might affect how they score behaviour | Double-blind |
In a repeated measures study, all participants do a memory test in silence and then with music. Why is this a problem, and how could it be fixed?
- By the second test, participants may have improved with practice or become tired: order effects.
- Counterbalancing: half do silence first, half do music first.
Answer: Order effects could affect the results; counterbalancing balances them across conditions.
Standardised procedures keep everything the same; counterbalancing balances order effects in repeated measures; randomisation uses chance to reduce bias; single-blind hides the condition from participants; double-blind hides it from participants and researchers.
- Counterbalancing
- In repeated measures, half the participants do condition A then B and half do B then A, to balance out order effects.
- Repeated measures
- An experimental design in which the same participants take part in all conditions.
- Double-blind
- Neither the participants nor the researcher collecting the data know which condition each participant is in.
- Demand characteristics
- Clues that let participants guess the aim of a study, so they change their behaviour.
Try two quick questions
See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.
2 more questions
Try each one, then tap to check.
What are order effects?
- Differences between participants
- Changes in the room
- Researcher mistakes
- Changes in performance caused by doing conditions in a certain order
Show the answer
Answer: Changes in performance caused by doing conditions in a certain order
Practice and fatigue are order effects.
Why are standardised procedures important?
- To make the study harder
- To vary conditions
- To remove the IV
- Every participant experiences the same conditions
Show the answer
Answer: Every participant experiences the same conditions
Standardisation allows replication.
Check you have got it
Answer 7 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.
Facts checked against the sources below, 17 October 2026. Last updated 2 October 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.
What do exam command words like explain and evaluate mean? โ