Key study: Piliavin et al. (1969) Good Samaritanism
Would people on a busy underground train help a man who collapsed? Piliavin and colleagues staged emergencies on the New York subway to find out.
Aim and procedure
Sample: about 4,450 passengers on the New York subway (around 45% black and 55% white), on weekdays between April and June 1968. There were 103 trials.
Procedure: a field experiment. Teams of four students (two female observers, a male 'victim' and a male 'model') boarded a train for a 7.5-minute non-stop journey. After about 70 seconds, the victim staggered forward and collapsed.
In the cane condition he appeared sober and carried a walking stick (ill); in the drunk condition he smelled of alcohol and carried a bottle in a paper bag.
If nobody helped, the model helped after about 70 or 150 seconds. Observers recorded who helped, how fast, and the number, race and sex of passengers.
Results and conclusion
Help usually came quickly. 90% of first helpers were male.
There was a slight tendency for same-race helping, mostly in the drunk condition.
There was no diffusion of responsibility: larger groups were not less likely to help.
Conclusion: Piliavin et al. proposed the arousal: cost-reward model: seeing an emergency causes unpleasant arousal, and people reduce it by weighing up the costs and rewards of helping. Helping a drunk person seems more costly (risk of harm or embarrassment) and less rewarding.
Strengths and weaknesses
Weaknesses: ethical issues: passengers did not give consent, were deceived, may have been distressed, and could not be debriefed. Little control over who was in the carriage, and some passengers may have seen more than one trial. Findings from New York in 1968 may not generalise.
Use the arousal: cost-reward model to explain why the drunk victim was helped less.
- Seeing someone collapse causes arousal that people want to reduce.
- Helping a drunk person has higher costs: he may be aggressive, sick or embarrassing.
- The rewards seem lower, as people may think he is to blame.
Answer: The costs of helping the drunk victim were higher and the rewards lower, so people were more likely to reduce their arousal by not helping.
Piliavin et al. staged collapses on the New York subway with about 4,450 passengers. The cane victim was helped on about 95% of trials, the drunk on about 50%. 90% of first helpers were male; there was no diffusion of responsibility. They proposed the arousal: cost-reward model. High ecological validity but ethical problems.
- Diffusion of responsibility
- Each person in a group feels less responsible for helping because others are present.
- Arousal: cost-reward model
- Piliavin et al.'s explanation of helping: seeing an emergency causes arousal, and people weigh up the costs and rewards of helping to reduce it.
- Ecological validity
- How far results apply to real-life settings.
- Validity
- Accuracy: whether a study measures what it claims to and whether results apply beyond the study.
- Field experiment
- An experiment in a natural, everyday setting in which the researcher still manipulates the IV.
- Demand characteristics
- Clues that let participants guess the aim of a study, so they change their behaviour.
Try two quick questions
See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.
2 more questions
Try each one, then tap to check.
Where was Piliavin et al.'s (1969) study carried out?
- In a university laboratory
- In a London hospital
- On the New York subway
- In a prison
Show the answer
Answer: On the New York subway
Trains on the New York subway gave a natural setting.
About how often was the cane victim helped?
- About 20% of trials
- About 50% of trials
- About 95% of trials
- Never
Show the answer
Answer: About 95% of trials
The ill victim was helped on almost every trial.
Check you have got it
Answer 7 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.
- Pearson Edexcel GCSE Psychology (1PS0) specification
- Simply Psychology: Piliavin et al. (1969) subway study
Facts checked against the sources below, 16 October 2026. Last updated 2 October 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.
What do exam command words like explain and evaluate mean? โ