Paper 2 Question 6: evaluating non-fiction

Question 6 asks you to evaluate how successfully the writer of Text 2 achieves something, for example sharing memories, persuading or presenting a place. It is worth 15 marks.

Practise this lesson free (6 questions)

More tools

Same skill, new text

Like Paper 1 Question 4, this is AO4: evaluate texts critically.
It is about how well, not just how. Examiner reports note that references to techniques should only be credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement.
Use the whole of Text 2 unless the question narrows it.

Practice: Text 2

Imagine the question: 'In this extract, the writer attempts to show that seaside towns are recovering. Evaluate how successfully this is achieved.'
Britain's seaside towns are fighting back. For years, cheap flights tempted families abroad, and many resorts were left with empty guesthouses and shuttered arcades. Now a new generation is rediscovering the coast. In Saltby, a former bingo hall has become an arts centre, and the old pier hosts a weekend food market. 'People want something real,' says one cafe owner. 'You can't buy a sunset like ours at the airport.' Not everyone is convinced: some residents complain that rising rents are pricing locals out. But walk along the front on a summer Saturday, and the crowds tell their own story.
Text 2. Practice extract, written for GCSE-ready

Judging non-fiction

Ask: Is it convincing? Is the evidence specific? Does the writer balance other views? Is the ending memorable?
You can make a mixed judgement: 'The writer is largely successful, although...'
Worked example

How successful is the writer of Text 2 at showing that seaside towns are recovering?

  1. Judgement: largely successful.
  2. Specific evidence: the bingo hall now an arts centre, a weekend food market.
  3. Balance: admitting rents are rising makes the writer seem fair, so more believable.
  4. Ending: the crowds image is vivid but is not hard evidence.

Answer: Largely successful: specific examples and a fair mention of rising rents make it convincing, though the final image of crowds is more impression than proof.

Key idea

Question 6: Text 2, AO4, 15 marks. Give clear judgements on how well the writer succeeds, support them with specific references, and consider balance, evidence and impact.

Quick check

Try two quick questions

See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.

Extra practice

2 more questions

Try each one, then tap to check.

  1. Which Paper 2 question evaluates Text 2?

    1. Question 6
    2. Question 1
    3. Question 7(a)
    4. Question 8
    Show the answer

    Answer: Question 6

    Question 6 is the AO4 evaluation question on Text 2.

  2. Why does including 'Not everyone is convinced' help the writer of Text 2?

    1. It shows the writer has changed their mind
    2. It makes the article seem balanced and fair, which makes the positive view more trustworthy
    3. It proves the towns are failing
    4. It ends the article
    Show the answer

    Answer: It makes the article seem balanced and fair, which makes the positive view more trustworthy

    Balance builds trust.

Check you have got it

Answer 6 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.

Sources and references

Facts checked against the sources below, 16 October 2026. Last updated 2 October 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.

Related lessons