Paper 1 Question 5: comparing two texts

Question 5 is the biggest reading question on Paper 1: 22 marks. You compare how the two texts present ideas and perspectives on a shared theme.

Practise this lesson free (6 questions)

More tools

What it asks

AO3: explore links and connections between writers' ideas and perspectives, and how they are conveyed.
You write about both texts: the unseen extract and the Anthology text.
Pearson's examiners advise making each point a valid comparison with references from both extracts, using comparative topic sentences, and not writing about one passage at length before moving on to the second.

Two practice texts

Shared theme: facing a fear.
ItemText One (swimming)Text Two (ice)
FearAdmits she was afraid; made excusesThe groaning ice frightens her
HelpBea's calm adviceFollowing the guide's tracks
OutcomeTriumph: she swims a lengthFear stays but is joined by wonder
ToneHonest, gently humorousTense, then awed

A comparative paragraph

'Both writers present fear honestly. In Text One the writer admits plainly, 'I was afraid', whereas in Text Two fear is shown through the ice that 'groaned'. However, the outcomes differ: Text One ends in triumph and a 'solemn thumbs up', while Text Two ends more quietly, with fear 'joined by wonder'.'
Worked example

Write a comparative topic sentence about how the two writers are helped.

  1. Text One: Bea's calm advice.
  2. Text Two: the guide's tracks.
  3. Link them with 'both' or 'whereas'.

Answer: Both writers rely on a calm guide figure: Bea's spoken advice in Text One and the guide's footsteps in Text Two.

Key idea

Question 5: AO3, 22 marks. Compare ideas and perspectives and how they are conveyed, point by point, with evidence from both texts and comparative topic sentences.

Quick check

Try two quick questions

See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.

Extra practice

2 more questions

Try each one, then tap to check.

  1. Paper 1 Question 5, the comparison of two texts, is worth how many marks?

    Show the answer

    Answer: 22

    Question 5 is worth 22 marks.

  2. Which sentence is an integrated comparison?

    1. Text One is about swimming.
    2. Text Two is about ice.
    3. I preferred Text One.
    4. Both writers face their fears, but while Text One ends in triumph, Text Two ends in quiet wonder
    Show the answer

    Answer: Both writers face their fears, but while Text One ends in triumph, Text Two ends in quiet wonder

    It links both texts in one point.

Check you have got it

Answer 6 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.

Video for this lesson coming soon. Subscribe on YouTube

Sources and references

Facts checked against the sources below, 16 October 2026. Last updated 2 October 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.

Related lessons