Identity and free will: Erikson and Baumeister

How does identity develop, and do we choose who we become? Erikson (1959) described stages of identity; Baumeister (2008) explored free will.

Practise this lesson free (7 questions)

More tools

Erikson (1959): eight stages

Erikson said identity develops across the whole life in eight stages. Each stage has a crisis (a conflict) to resolve. Resolving it well gives a healthy sense of self; failing leaves problems.
Stage (rough age)Crisis
1. Infancy (0 to 1)Trust versus mistrust
2. Early childhood (1 to 3)Autonomy versus shame and doubt
3. Play age (3 to 6)Initiative versus guilt
4. School age (6 to 12)Industry versus inferiority
5. Adolescence (12 to 18)Identity versus role confusion
6. Young adulthoodIntimacy versus isolation
7. Middle adulthoodGenerativity versus stagnation
8. Old ageEgo integrity versus despair

Evaluating Erikson

Strengths: it covers the whole lifespan, not just childhood. It recognises the role of society and relationships. Stage 5 helps explain why teenagers try out different identities.
Weaknesses: the ages are vague and people may not go through the stages in a fixed order. It is hard to test scientifically. It was based on Western society, so may not apply to all cultures.

Baumeister (2008): free will

Free will is the belief that we choose our own actions. Determinism is the opposite idea: our behaviour is caused by things outside our control, such as genes or upbringing.
Baumeister argued that free will is real as a psychological ability: it involves self-control and making rational choices, and it evolved to help humans live in complex cultures with rules.
Believing in free will makes people take more responsibility for their actions; studies such as Vohs and Schooler (2008) found that weakening this belief increased cheating.
Strengths: supported by experimental evidence; it gives a scientific way to study free will.
Weaknesses: free will is very hard to define and measure. Much behaviour may be caused by genes, upbringing or unconscious processes, so people may only feel free.
Worked example

A 15-year-old keeps changing her style, music and friends. Using Erikson, explain what is happening.

  1. She is in stage 5, adolescence: identity versus role confusion.
  2. Trying out different roles is part of working out a stable identity.

Answer: She is resolving the identity versus role confusion crisis by experimenting with roles.

Key idea

Erikson (1959) described eight life stages, each with a crisis; adolescence is identity versus role confusion. Baumeister (2008) saw free will as self-control and rational choice that evolved for life in culture, and belief in it encourages responsible behaviour.

Key words
Free will
The belief that people choose their own actions, rather than behaviour being caused by outside forces.
Culture
The shared beliefs, values, norms and customs of a group, passed from one generation to the next.
Determinism
The view that behaviour is caused by factors outside our control, such as genes or upbringing.

All GCSE Psychology key terms and definitions โ†’

Quick check

Try two quick questions

See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.

Extra practice

2 more questions

Try each one, then tap to check.

  1. What happens if a teenager fails to resolve Erikson's adolescent crisis?

    1. Strong identity
    2. Role confusion
    3. Trust
    4. Ego integrity
    Show the answer

    Answer: Role confusion

    Confusion about who they are.

  2. Which is the last of Erikson's stages?

    1. Trust versus mistrust
    2. Identity versus role confusion
    3. Ego integrity versus despair
    4. Industry versus inferiority
    Show the answer

    Answer: Ego integrity versus despair

    Older adults reflect on their lives.

Check you have got it

Answer 7 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.

Video for this lesson coming soon. Subscribe on YouTube

Sources and references

Facts checked against the sources below, 17 October 2026. Last updated 2 October 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.

What do exam command words like explain and evaluate mean? โ†’

Related lessons