Tropical cyclones: impacts and responses
The same kind of storm can have very different impacts in a rich country and a poorer one. Two well-known storms show why.
Why cyclones are hazardous
Intense rainfall causes river flooding and landslides.
Storm surges push the sea onto low-lying coasts, causing coastal flooding: often the biggest killer.
The Saffir-Simpson scale rates hurricanes from Category 1 to Category 5 by wind speed.
Developed country: Hurricane Katrina, USA, 2005
In New Orleans, much of which lies below sea level, the storm surge broke the levees and about 80% of the city flooded. More than 1,800 people died.
Responses: a mandatory evacuation was ordered, but many poorer residents without cars could not leave. The Superdome stadium became a shelter. The government was strongly criticised for its slow response. Afterwards the flood defences around New Orleans were rebuilt and strengthened.
Emerging country: Typhoon Haiyan, Philippines, 2013
A huge storm surge flooded the city of Tacloban. More than 6,000 people died and millions lost their homes.
Responses: warnings were given and many people evacuated, but some did not understand what a 'storm surge' meant. International aid arrived from many countries and charities, and the government later planned to rebuild coastal communities further from the sea.
How effective were the responses?
Katrina, what worked: about 1.2 million people, over 90% of the affected population, were evacuated before the storm reached the coast.
Katrina, what did not: about 100,000 people stayed in New Orleans, many of them poorer residents with no car. About 26,000 people sheltered in the Superdome, and moving them out was not finished until 3 September, five days after landfall. The levees failed, and troops were criticised for arriving too slowly.
Haiyan, what worked: nearly 800,000 people were in evacuation centres, and international aid arrived from many countries.
Haiyan, what did not: many residents and local leaders did not know the term 'storm surge', and warnings sounded like a rain warning. Many evacuation centres were single-storey schools inside the surge zone, so some flooded and people sheltering inside were killed.
Verdict: both responses were only partly effective. Wealth helped the USA evacuate most people and, later, rebuild its flood defences, but planning failed the poorest. In the Philippines, warnings reached people but were not understood, and shelters were in the wrong places.
Suggest why Haiyan killed more people than Katrina.
- Many homes in the Philippines were lightly built and on low coasts.
- Poorer people had fewer ways to evacuate or protect themselves.
- Haiyan was stronger at landfall, with a very large storm surge.
Answer: Stronger storm, more vulnerable housing and people, and a huge storm surge.
Cyclones bring high winds, intense rain, landslides and storm surges. Katrina (USA, 2005) flooded about 80% of New Orleans and killed over 1,800. Haiyan (Philippines, 2013) killed over 6,000. Impacts and responses depend on wealth, preparation and governance. To judge a response, weigh what worked against what did not: both were only partly effective.
- Storm surge
- A rise in sea level caused by low pressure and strong winds pushing water onto the coast.
- Aid
- Help given by one country or organisation to another, such as money, goods or expertise. It can be bilateral, multilateral, emergency or long-term.
All GCSE and International GCSE Geography A key terms and definitions →
- Not “Richter scale”. The Richter scale measures earthquakes.
- Not “They were too far inland to reach”. Being inland would have made them safer from the surge.
- Not “They were built on high mountains”. High ground is safe from a storm surge.
- Not “They were closed before the storm”. The centres were open and nearly 800,000 people used them.
Try two quick questions
See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.
2 more questions
Try each one, then tap to check.
Why are storm surges especially deadly on low-lying coasts?
- They only affect mountains
- They bring hail
- Seawater can flood far inland very quickly
- They move slowly over months
Show the answer
Answer: Seawater can flood far inland very quickly
The surge pushes the sea over low land.
In which year did Hurricane Katrina hit New Orleans?
- 2005
- 2013
- 1998
- 2012
Show the answer
Answer: 2005
Katrina hit New Orleans in August 2005.
Check you have got it
Answer 9 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.
- Pearson Edexcel GCSE Geography A (1GA0) specification, topic Paper 1, Topic 2: 2.6
- Pearson Edexcel International GCSE Geography A (4GE1) specification, topic Paper 1, Topic 3: 3.2c
- NWS Mobile: Hurricane Katrina, August 2005
- ReliefWeb: Typhoon Haiyan, a decade later
- 64 Parishes: Hurricane Katrina
- Rappler: 800,000 evacuated as Yolanda hits
- Humanitarian Practice Network: Assessing early warning efforts for Typhoon Haiyan in Leyte
Facts checked against the sources below, 9 November 2026. Last updated 9 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.
What do exam command words like explain and evaluate mean? →