Evaluating a text: Paper 1 Question 4

Question 4 is the biggest reading question on Paper 1: 15 marks. It asks you to evaluate how successfully the writer achieves something, such as tension or a sense of character.

Practise this lesson free (6 questions)

More tools

What evaluation means

Analysis asks how a writer creates an effect. Evaluation asks how well it works.
A typical task: 'In this extract, there is an attempt to create tension. Evaluate how successfully this is achieved. Support your views with detailed reference to the text.'
You give a judgement, back it with evidence and explain why it works.

Evaluative language

Use words that judge: successfully, effectively, convincingly, powerfully, vividly, cleverly, gradually builds.
Example: 'The writer very effectively builds tension by slowing the pace as the footsteps climb the stairs.'
Mention methods only when they support your judgement. Examiners say that references to techniques are only credited at Level 2 and above if they support the critical judgement.

How it is marked

Question 4 is marked in five levels.
LevelMarksTypical answer
11 to 3Simple comments, little evidence
24 to 6Some judgement with some evidence
37 to 9Clear judgement with relevant evidence
410 to 12Thorough, well supported evaluation
513 to 15Perceptive, critical evaluation with apt, discriminating evidence
Worked example

Write an evaluative sentence about the ending of the Mr Pellow extract (printed with Quick check question 2 below).

  1. Judgement: the ending is very successful.
  2. Evidence: 'very gently, the handle began to turn'.
  3. Why: the gentle movement is more frightening than a crash, and the extract stops before we see who it is.

Answer: The ending is highly effective: the handle turning 'very gently' is more unsettling than a loud entrance, and stopping there leaves the reader in suspense.

Key idea

Question 4 = AO4, 15 marks. Make a judgement about how successfully the writer achieves the effect, support it with well-chosen references, and use methods only to back your judgement.

Key words
Tension
A feeling of anxious suspense that makes the reader want to know what happens next.
Pace
The speed at which events unfold or a text reads. Short sentences can quicken pace; long ones can slow it.

All GCSE and International GCSE English Language key terms and definitions โ†’

Quick check

Try two quick questions

See if it has sunk in. Answers are marked straight away.

Extra practice

2 more questions

Try each one, then tap to check.

  1. Which sentence is evaluation rather than analysis?

    1. The clock "ticked heavily", which is a verb
    2. The writer's use of the ticking clock is highly effective at making the wait feel unbearable
    3. The writer mentions a clock
    4. The story is about a man in an office
    Show the answer

    Answer: The writer's use of the ticking clock is highly effective at making the wait feel unbearable

    Evaluation judges how successful the writer's choice is, here "highly effective".

  2. Which sentence about the extract is the most evaluative?

    1. Ending as the handle "began to turn" is a brilliantly tense way to stop, because the reader never learns who is there
    2. The handle turns at the end
    3. The writer uses the word "handle"
    4. The extract is set in a counting-house
    Show the answer

    Answer: Ending as the handle "began to turn" is a brilliantly tense way to stop, because the reader never learns who is there

    It judges ("brilliantly tense"), gives evidence and explains why it works.

Check you have got it

Answer 6 quick questions with instant marking. If you get one wrong, GCSE-ready shows you why and gives you another go. It is free, and you do not need an account.

Sources and references

Facts checked against the sources below, 16 October 2026. Last updated 2 October 2026. Spotted a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.

Related lessons